The only sound in the tent was the soft scratching of Kuro's brush against the endless scroll as the scholar continued writing, his expression unreadable. Kai studied him carefully, trying to discern any reaction—approval, suspicion, disappointment—but the man's face remained an impassive mask of scholarly focus.

  Then came the sniffles.

  At first, it was just a small, wet sound—barely noticeable. Then another. Kai turned to his left and was met with a sight that would have been comical if it weren't so unexpectedly touching: Lu Bu, Zhang Liao, and Gin, all in various states of emotional devastation.

  Lu Bu's usual boundless energy had melted into unrestrained weeping, his face scrunched up like a child who'd just dropped his favorite sweet in the dirt. Tears streamed down his cheeks in fat droplets, his shoulders shaking with each hiccupping sob. Zhang Liao, ever the more reserved of the two, was faring slightly better—but only just. His quiet sniffles and red-rimmed eyes betrayed how deeply Kai's story had affected him.

  But it was Gin who was the most dramatic.

  The drunkard was a complete wreck—his face red and puffy, tears streaming down his cheeks in torrents. Snot dripped freely from his nose, and he made no effort to wipe it away as he blubbered openly.

  "Waaah! Oh, Kai!" Gin blubbered, his voice thick with emotion. "I always thought you had it easy—joining a proper sect and all that! But you... you suffered just like the rest of us!" He lurched forward, arms outstretched for a hug, his entire body trembling with the force of his sobs. "And those bastards tried to make you kill your Beastkin! Those heartless, soulless—"

  Kai recoiled as Gin's snot-dripping face came dangerously close to his shoulder. "Gin—Gin, no—" He planted a firm hand on the man's chest, holding him at arm's length. "Control yourself! You're getting... snot everywhere."

  Gin ignored him, still sniffling pathetically. "They ordered you to kill your own family? How could they make you do such a thing!"

  Lu Bu, despite his tears, suddenly perked up, his expression shifting to awe. "Big Brother Igni and Snow saved you from that evil snake?! They're even more amazing than I thought!" He turned to Zhang Liao, shaking his shoulder excitedly. "Did you hear that? They fought a giant demon serpent for Uncle Kai!"

  Zhang Liao nodded, his voice trembling slightly. "A-And you were going to sacrifice yourself to protect them..." He swallowed hard, wiping his eyes again. "I'm so glad you survived."

  Kai shifted uncomfortably under the weight of their tears, his calloused fingers tightening around his teacup until the clay threatened to crack. The raw emotion in the tent—Gin's drunken sobbing, Lu Bu's wide-eyed admiration, even Zhang Liao's quiet sniffles—felt unusual to Kai.

  No one had ever cried for him before.

  Not when the Ember Sword Sect's discipline masters had broken three of his ribs for failing a technique. Not when he was ill. Not even when he was marked for death by the Jade King’s seal.

  The Beastkin had grieved for him in their own way—licking his wounds, curling around him at night, their low whines vibrating through his bones when the pain was too much. But cultivators? Cultivators had only ever given him scorn, or indifference, or the cold calculus of whether he was still useful enough to keep alive.

  Then, from the other side of the table, Kuro finally set down his brush.

  The scholar's eyes lifted from the scroll, his expression unreadable.

  "That," he said slowly, "was not the story I was expecting."

  A heavy silence fell over the tent.

  Kai tensed.

  “Did my story displease you, Great Senior… I mean, Mr. Kuro?” Kai’s voice was tighter than he intended, the honorific slipping out unbidden.

  Kuro did not look up from his scroll. “No, there is nothing wrong with your story,” he said, his tone that of a librarian assessing a moderately interesting text. “It has all the requisite trappings of a compelling narrative—tragedy, loss, a touch of self-sacrifice. It was simply… not the story I was looking for.”

  The dismissal was gentle, yet it still stung a little. It wasn’t anger or disappointment in Kuro’s voice, but something akin to academic disinterest.

  “Oh,” Kai said, thrown completely off balance. A hollow feeling opened in his chest. “I’m… sorry?”

  “Don’t be,” Kuro replied, finally glancing up with a smile that was neither warm nor cold, but simply factual. “It is the story of your life. You can only live the life you are given.”

  It was Lu Bu, ever earnest and unable to abide any slight against his master, who broke the tense silence. “What kind of story were you looking for?” he asked, his brow furrowed in confusion.

  “I was searching for the story of a hero. A narrative of grand purpose and destiny. Unfortunately, Mr. Kai’s story is not one of those.”

  “My Uncle Kai is a hero!” Lu Bu protested instantly, leaping to his feet. His young face was flushed with indignant loyalty. “He saved us! He protects everyone here! He’s the bravest person I know!”

  Kuro’s expression softened into something akin to pity. “I am sure he is, from your perspective. And based on the tale he told of saving you, he certainly performed a heroic act. But a single act, however noble, does not make a hero’s story. A true hero’s tale is one of unwavering conviction, of charging headlong into destiny. Your uncle’s story, by his own admission, is one of… running away. Of turning his back on what is right. Of choosing a quiet life over a meaningful struggle. It is the story of a man who saw the corruption of the world and decided to hide from it rather than fight it.” He turned his calm, dissecting gaze back to Kai. “Unfortunately, that makes him a bit of a coward.”

  This book's true home is on another platform. Check it out there for the real experience.

  The word—coward—hung in the air, stark and brutal.

  It hit Kai hard. Because, in a devastating, shameful corner of his heart that he never dared to examine, Kai feared Kuro might be right.

  Lu Bu shot to his feet, his small frame trembling with outrage. "My Uncle Kai is NOT a coward!" he yelled, his voice cracking with a mixture of fury and fierce loyalty. His fists were clenched so tightly that his knuckles were white.

  Across the table, Lulu visibly paled. She looked as if she were ready to vault over the wooden table and physically clamp a hand over the boy's mouth.

  Kuro remained unnervingly calm. He turned his placid gaze from the furious boy back to Kai. "But is he not?" he asked, his voice deceptively soft. "Tell me, Kai—when you discovered that merchant in Wuyuan City purchasing refugee children for slaves, and you had the power to stop him... did you not choose to do nothing?"

  Lu Bu's defiant posture faltered. The memory surfaced in his mind of that interaction with Sato. He had never voiced his disagreement aloud, but a part of him had deeply disagreed with Kai's decision to walk away.

  Kai's jaw tightened. "What would you have had me do? Cut him down in the street?" he retorted, a defensive edge sharpening his tone. "I have enough blood on my hands. And killing him might have made things worse. However corrupt, he was the only one providing food to those people. Removing him could have caused more starvation."

  "Excuses," Kuro stated flatly, the word landing like a stone. "They are a coward's favorite tool—crafted to rationalize inaction and absolve oneself of guilt." He didn't raise his voice, but each syllable carried the weight of cold, hard truth. "It is the same rationale you used when you fled that mortal village under attack by the demonic cultivators. Righteous cultivators had arrived, so you told yourself they didn't need you. You convinced yourself they would handle it, even though you claimed to care for those people. You ran because it was safer, because the Ember Sword Sect had already discarded you, and you saw no reason to bleed for a sect that had shown you no kindness."

  "WHAT WOULD YOU HAVE HAD ME DO?" Kai exploded, surging to his feet. The words tore from him, raw and unguarded. "Throw myself into a fight I couldn't win? Die for a sect that viewed me as expendable?!"

  The moment the words left his mouth, a cold wave of horror washed over him. The tent fell into a dead silence. He had just screamed at a cultivator who was, at minimum, at the Nascent Soul realm—a being who could unmake him with a thought. He braced himself for retribution, his heart hammering against his ribs.

  But Kuro did not anger. Instead, a warm, almost paternal smile spread across his face. It was the most genuine expression Kai had seen from him yet.

  "If you had fought," Kuro said calmly, "then I would have called you a fool."

  He began carefully rolling his endless scroll, his movements unhurried. "I apologize if you felt I was insulting you or passing judgment. That was not my intention. It seems... some of my own worldview slipped out."

  Chen Gong, who had been observing the exchange with a scholar's intense focus, leaned forward. "What do you mean by that—your worldview?"

  Kuro fell silent for a long moment, his gaze turning inward as if consulting a vast library of lived experience contained within his own mind. The air in the tent grew heavy with the weight of his contemplation.

  "After ages of wandering," he began, his voice taking on a resonant, almost ceremonial quality, "after recording the triumphs and tragedies of emperors and beggars, immortal masters and mortal farmers, I have observed a fundamental pattern in the tapestry of existence."

  He paused, carefully choosing his words. "Whether mortal or cultivator, rich or poor, powerful or weak—all people eventually reveal themselves to belong to one of two broad categories: cowards or fools."

  He held up a single finger. "The cowards are those who possess the wisdom to survive but lack the courage to truly live. They see injustice and calculate the risk. They witness suffering and rationalize their inaction. They live long lives, but their souls are slowly eroded by the constant compromise of their own values. Every time they look away, every time they tell themselves 'it is not my problem,' a small part of them dies. They die not in a single glorious moment, but in a thousand tiny surrenders."

  He raised a second finger. "The fools are those who possess the courage to act but lack the wisdom or strength to succeed. They see wrongs that must be righted and charge forward without counting the cost—to themselves or to those who depend on them. They die young on forgotten battlefields, in hopeless rebellions, in noble but futile gestures. They leave behind grieving families and unresolved problems, their bravery remembered in songs that change nothing."

  Kuro's hands fell to his sides, and a profound sadness filled his expression. "Some philosophers might argue it's better to die a fool than live a coward—that honor matters more than longevity. But the dead cannot build a better world. Others might claim it's wiser to live as a coward than die a fool—that survival is the ultimate virtue. But what value has a life spent in constant fear and self-betrayal?"

  He looked around the tent, his eyes lingering on each face. "This... this is the terrible dichotomy I have observed across the world for most of my life. It is a worldview I do not enjoy holding, but one that experience has forced upon me."

  Then his gaze settled on Kai, intense and searching. "That is why I sought you out when my Dao whispered that your story might be different. I had dared to hope—perhaps fooling myself—that yours might finally be the story of a hero."

  A complex emotion crossed Kuro's features—part disappointment, part understanding. "For a true hero would be neither coward nor fool. A hero would possess both the courage to act and the wisdom to succeed. The existence of even one such person would prove my cynical worldview wrong. It would mean the universe is not fundamentally divided between those who won't fight and those who can't win."

  He sighed, the sound carrying the weight of centuries of disappointment. "Alas, I have yet to find such a hero. The closest I've encountered were perhaps fools who managed to live a little longer than most, or cowards who occasionally mustered a moment of unexpected bravery. But never both qualities sustained in one person across a lifetime."

  Kuro's shoulders slumped slightly. "Your story, Kai, is compelling. But it is not the story that will redeem my faith in this world. You have moments of astonishing bravery—saving these children, protecting your Beastkin. But you also have your retreats, your compromises, your calculations. You are, in the end, like all the others whose stories I have collected."

  The tent fell into a profound silence after Kuro's speech. It was in this heavy quiet that a small, clear voice spoke up.

  "If you think everyone is either a fool or a coward," Zhang Liao asked, his youthful face a mask of genuine, uncomplicated curiosity, "then what are you?"

  For a single, heart-stopping moment, the world seemed to freeze. Kai, Lulu, and Gin all turned identical looks of pure horror toward the boy. Of all the disciples, they had least expected the quiet, observant Zhang Liao to voice the question that could unravel everything. It was the kind of deeply personal, potentially insulting inquiry that could make a lesser cultivator vaporize a child on the spot for the impertinence.

  But Kuro still did not get angry. Instead, a remarkable transformation came over the scholar. The ancient weariness that had lined his features seemed to soften, and his smile this time was different.

  He chuckled, a sound that was both warm and sad. “I’m both a coward and a fool. Someone who was too scared to chase their dreams. And, someone who still foolishly looks for heroes in this world.”

  Patreon! You can read chapters early by becoming a patron.